Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)

In many developing countries, Public-Private Partnership (PPP) has shown an increased reliance not only for infrastructure development but it has expanded in other sectors that including social housing (affordable houses). However, there are evident in previous literature on the accounts of lacking...

Full description

Saved in:

Bibliographic Details
Main Author:	Putri Zulaiha, Razi
Format:	Thesis
Language:	English
Published:	2020
Subjects:	TA Engineering (General) Civil engineering (General)
Online Access:	http://umpir.ump.edu.my/id/eprint/33678/1/Risk%20management%20framework%20for%20the%20delivery%20of%20public.pdf
Tags:	Add Tag No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!

id	my-ump-ir.33678
record_format	uketd_dc
spelling	my-ump-ir.336782022-04-11T06:37:17Z Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma) 2020-11 Putri Zulaiha, Razi TA Engineering (General). Civil engineering (General) In many developing countries, Public-Private Partnership (PPP) has shown an increased reliance not only for infrastructure development but it has expanded in other sectors that including social housing (affordable houses). However, there are evident in previous literature on the accounts of lacking success reporting on the PPP housing approach, plus inadequacy of proper evaluation for PPP performance projects. This study aims to develop a risk management framework based upon the derived risk index determined by the analysis of quantitative Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), used as an indicator for the project performance score. This study is designed in three (3) phases by employing a mixed-method approach (qualitative and quantitative). Results demonstrated that a total 9 risk elements and 33 sub-elements obtained from the literature review and was validated during pilot study, by employing semi-structured interview, with eight (8) PPP housing construction experts. The data set for the study comprised thirty-three (33) construction experts involved in the PPP housing construction project. Results showed that natural hazard risk (geologic hazard risk) and economic and financial risk (inflation and interest rate) risk prevails as extreme external risks that influenced PPP housing project performance more than the market and social-politics risk. On the contrary, unreliable value for money and fluctuation in the currency exchange rate of economic and financial risks discovered as moderately influenced PPP housing project performance. Similarly, project-related risk (internal) in procurement and contractual risks that including (absence of transparency and accountability during the procurement process, and absence of a robust and clear agreement) discovered will moderately affect the delivery of PPP housing project performance risks. Akin in moderating the effect in technical faulty risks are (unforeseen ground condition and shortage of technical expertise). Eventually, it was found that internal risks monopolized the low risks occupied within the risk index of (0.000 < RI ≤ 0.050) including insufficient capacity in procurement and negotiation, frequent design change, design over-specification, poor quality workmanship, absence of specific PPP framework and inadequate PPP skills and knowledge leading to poor planning. While captured from external risks are financial incapacity of private partners, weak state intervention, and persistent land acquisition. Risk response strategy for the extreme risks categorized within (0.100 < RI ≤ 0.150) is by avoiding the risk and best to assign the risks to the private sector. On the contrary, risk response approaches suggested considering the medium risks categorized at interval (0.050 < RI ≤ 0.100), is to transfer the risks and shared within both parties, i.e. public and private. While for low risks lies between (0.000 < RI ≤ 0.050), all the risks best to accept and retained within the public sectors. Taken together, the development of risk response and risk mitigation plan that emerged from the risk index offered significant contribution which has gain a new understanding that risks with severe or low exposure can be reduced or avoided taking into account its strategic and effective response and mitigation approaches. The developed risk management framework is expected to assist the successful implementation of risk management for the PPP housing project and the success of the PPP housing project. 2020-11 Thesis http://umpir.ump.edu.my/id/eprint/33678/ http://umpir.ump.edu.my/id/eprint/33678/1/Risk%20management%20framework%20for%20the%20delivery%20of%20public.pdf pdf en public phd doctoral Universiti Malaysia Pahang College of Engineering
institution	Universiti Malaysia Pahang Al-Sultan Abdullah
collection	UMPSA Institutional Repository
language	English
topic	TA Engineering (General) Civil engineering (General)
spellingShingle	TA Engineering (General) Civil engineering (General) Putri Zulaiha, Razi Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
description	In many developing countries, Public-Private Partnership (PPP) has shown an increased reliance not only for infrastructure development but it has expanded in other sectors that including social housing (affordable houses). However, there are evident in previous literature on the accounts of lacking success reporting on the PPP housing approach, plus inadequacy of proper evaluation for PPP performance projects. This study aims to develop a risk management framework based upon the derived risk index determined by the analysis of quantitative Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), used as an indicator for the project performance score. This study is designed in three (3) phases by employing a mixed-method approach (qualitative and quantitative). Results demonstrated that a total 9 risk elements and 33 sub-elements obtained from the literature review and was validated during pilot study, by employing semi-structured interview, with eight (8) PPP housing construction experts. The data set for the study comprised thirty-three (33) construction experts involved in the PPP housing construction project. Results showed that natural hazard risk (geologic hazard risk) and economic and financial risk (inflation and interest rate) risk prevails as extreme external risks that influenced PPP housing project performance more than the market and social-politics risk. On the contrary, unreliable value for money and fluctuation in the currency exchange rate of economic and financial risks discovered as moderately influenced PPP housing project performance. Similarly, project-related risk (internal) in procurement and contractual risks that including (absence of transparency and accountability during the procurement process, and absence of a robust and clear agreement) discovered will moderately affect the delivery of PPP housing project performance risks. Akin in moderating the effect in technical faulty risks are (unforeseen ground condition and shortage of technical expertise). Eventually, it was found that internal risks monopolized the low risks occupied within the risk index of (0.000 < RI ≤ 0.050) including insufficient capacity in procurement and negotiation, frequent design change, design over-specification, poor quality workmanship, absence of specific PPP framework and inadequate PPP skills and knowledge leading to poor planning. While captured from external risks are financial incapacity of private partners, weak state intervention, and persistent land acquisition. Risk response strategy for the extreme risks categorized within (0.100 < RI ≤ 0.150) is by avoiding the risk and best to assign the risks to the private sector. On the contrary, risk response approaches suggested considering the medium risks categorized at interval (0.050 < RI ≤ 0.100), is to transfer the risks and shared within both parties, i.e. public and private. While for low risks lies between (0.000 < RI ≤ 0.050), all the risks best to accept and retained within the public sectors. Taken together, the development of risk response and risk mitigation plan that emerged from the risk index offered significant contribution which has gain a new understanding that risks with severe or low exposure can be reduced or avoided taking into account its strategic and effective response and mitigation approaches. The developed risk management framework is expected to assist the successful implementation of risk management for the PPP housing project and the success of the PPP housing project.
format	Thesis
qualification_name	Doctor of Philosophy (PhD.)
qualification_level	Doctorate
author	Putri Zulaiha, Razi
author_facet	Putri Zulaiha, Razi
author_sort	Putri Zulaiha, Razi
title	Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
title_short	Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
title_full	Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
title_fullStr	Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
title_full_unstemmed	Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
title_sort	risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)
granting_institution	Universiti Malaysia Pahang
granting_department	College of Engineering
publishDate	2020
url	http://umpir.ump.edu.my/id/eprint/33678/1/Risk%20management%20framework%20for%20the%20delivery%20of%20public.pdf
_version_	1783732174291206144

Risk management framework for the delivery of public-private partnership (ppp) housing construction project : case study of malaysia housing programme (pr1ma)

Similar Items