Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application

The Fifth generation communication offers many benefits such as massive system capacity,very high data rate and low latency.Microstrip array antenna were popular due to the easiness of design and fabrication process.Besides, the microstrip array antenna is also popular for backhaul application. To...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Author: Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff
Format: Thesis
Language:English
English
Published: 2018
Subjects:
Online Access:http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/1/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf
http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/2/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
id my-utem-ep.23288
record_format uketd_dc
institution Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka
collection UTeM Repository
language English
English
topic T Technology (General)
T Technology (General)
spellingShingle T Technology (General)
T Technology (General)
Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff
Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
description The Fifth generation communication offers many benefits such as massive system capacity,very high data rate and low latency.Microstrip array antenna were popular due to the easiness of design and fabrication process.Besides, the microstrip array antenna is also popular for backhaul application. To enhance the performance of microstrip array antenna,the FSS has been integrated to the antenna structure.The Frequency Selective Surface (FSS) is based on metamaterial are the substitute to the fixed frequency metamaterials with static geometry and spacing in the unit cells used to find out the frequency response of a given metamaterial.FSS with specific geometrical shapes can be made-up as periodic arrays with elements of two dimensional.Antenna specification for return loss is below than -10 dB,but in practical field,the reflection coefficient of the signal always fluctuates,so it is giving unstable value for return loss.The directivity of the antenna depends on the antenna design.Since this antenna element is microstrip array antenna,the antenna performance will change by the additional patch.The integration with the FSS will be affected towards the return loss of the antenna.The design of antenna and Frequency Selective Surface is at 28 GHz on the Rogers Duroid RT5880 board with the thickness of substrate is 0.254 mm and copper thickness is 0.017 mm with dielectric constant of 2.2 and the tangent loss is 0.0009.The antennas was design from single patch antenna until 32-element patch array antenna by using the quarter wave theory to feed at 50 Ω,70 Ω and 100 Ω.The FSS design on this research was held on three designs which are triangular loop,hexagonal loop and rectangular loop.From the simulation the triangular loop had the best result on return loss is -30.832 dB at 28 GHz.The rectangular antenna has been choosen due to the best result on single design which is -49.48 dB,next the single design has evolved to 32-element patch array antenna and the result is decreased to -37.62 dB.The 32 -element patch array antenna are integrated with triangular loop FSS,the return loss is better which is -64.67 dB.The simulation is done using microwave CST software.The fabrication process involves the photo etching technique.The return loss measurement on integrated antenna with FSS gives a minimum resonant -43.55 dB at 28.45 GHz,slightly shifted from the simulation result.The antenna directivity was recorded of 21.7 dBi.
format Thesis
qualification_name Master of Philosophy (M.Phil.)
qualification_level Master's degree
author Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff
author_facet Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff
author_sort Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff
title Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
title_short Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
title_full Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
title_fullStr Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
title_full_unstemmed Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application
title_sort performance enhancement with triangular loop frequency selective surface on microstrip array antenna for 5g application
granting_institution UTeM
granting_department Faculty Of Electronic And Computer Engineering
publishDate 2018
url http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/1/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf
http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/2/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf
_version_ 1747834027910365184
spelling my-utem-ep.232882022-03-15T10:00:06Z Performance Enhancement With Triangular Loop Frequency Selective Surface On Microstrip Array Antenna For 5G Application 2018 Abd Rahim, Muhamad Akliff T Technology (General) TK Electrical engineering. Electronics Nuclear engineering The Fifth generation communication offers many benefits such as massive system capacity,very high data rate and low latency.Microstrip array antenna were popular due to the easiness of design and fabrication process.Besides, the microstrip array antenna is also popular for backhaul application. To enhance the performance of microstrip array antenna,the FSS has been integrated to the antenna structure.The Frequency Selective Surface (FSS) is based on metamaterial are the substitute to the fixed frequency metamaterials with static geometry and spacing in the unit cells used to find out the frequency response of a given metamaterial.FSS with specific geometrical shapes can be made-up as periodic arrays with elements of two dimensional.Antenna specification for return loss is below than -10 dB,but in practical field,the reflection coefficient of the signal always fluctuates,so it is giving unstable value for return loss.The directivity of the antenna depends on the antenna design.Since this antenna element is microstrip array antenna,the antenna performance will change by the additional patch.The integration with the FSS will be affected towards the return loss of the antenna.The design of antenna and Frequency Selective Surface is at 28 GHz on the Rogers Duroid RT5880 board with the thickness of substrate is 0.254 mm and copper thickness is 0.017 mm with dielectric constant of 2.2 and the tangent loss is 0.0009.The antennas was design from single patch antenna until 32-element patch array antenna by using the quarter wave theory to feed at 50 Ω,70 Ω and 100 Ω.The FSS design on this research was held on three designs which are triangular loop,hexagonal loop and rectangular loop.From the simulation the triangular loop had the best result on return loss is -30.832 dB at 28 GHz.The rectangular antenna has been choosen due to the best result on single design which is -49.48 dB,next the single design has evolved to 32-element patch array antenna and the result is decreased to -37.62 dB.The 32 -element patch array antenna are integrated with triangular loop FSS,the return loss is better which is -64.67 dB.The simulation is done using microwave CST software.The fabrication process involves the photo etching technique.The return loss measurement on integrated antenna with FSS gives a minimum resonant -43.55 dB at 28.45 GHz,slightly shifted from the simulation result.The antenna directivity was recorded of 21.7 dBi. 2018 Thesis http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/ http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/1/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf text en public http://eprints.utem.edu.my/id/eprint/23288/2/Performance%20Enhancement%20With%20Triangular%20Loop%20Frequency%20Selective%20Surface%20On%20Microstrip%20Array%20Antenna%20For%205G%20Application.pdf text en validuser https://plh.utem.edu.my/cgi-bin/koha/opac-detail.pl?biblionumber=112727 mphil masters UTeM Faculty Of Electronic And Computer Engineering 1. Abdel-rahman, A.B. and Ibrahim, A.A., 2016. Metamaterial Enhances Microstrip Antenna Gain, (August), pp.47–49. 2. Abu, M., Rahim, M.K.A., Ayop, O., and Zubir F., 2010. Triple-Band prnted Dipole Antenna with single band AMC-HIS. Progress In Electromagnetics Research B, 20, pp.225–244. 3. Ahmad, K., 2012. Network Congestion Control in 4G Technology Through Iterative Server, 9 (4), pp.343–348. 4. Al-Waidh, A., 2009. Metamaterials [online]. Available at: www.docstoc.com/docs/168056622/metamaterials [Accessed 9 Sep 2017]. 5. Ali, M.M.M. and Sebak, A.R., 2016. Dual band (28/38 GHz) CPW slot directive antenna for future 5G cellular applications. 2016 IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium, APSURSI 2016 - Proceedings, pp.399–400. 6. Andrews, J.G.J.G., Buzzi, S., Choi, W., Hanly, S.V.S.V., Lozano, A., Soong, A.C.K.A.C.K., and Zhang, J.C.J.C., 2014. What will 5G be? IEEE Journal on Selected Areas in Communications, 32 (6), pp.1065–1082. 7. Aravamudhan, L.S., Faccin, R., Mononen, B., Patil, Y., Saifullah, S., S., S., and Sreemanthula, 2015. Second-Generation Mobile Networks [online]. Available at: http://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=98132&seqNum=4 [Accessed 19 Nov 2016]. 8. Aseri, K., Yadav, S., and Sharma, M.M., 2015. A Compact Frequency Selective Surface Based Band-Stop Filter for WLAN Applications. 2015 Fifth International Conference on Communication Systems and Network Technologies, pp.328–332.117 9. Ayad, H., Fadlallah, M., Youssef, H., Elmokdad, H., Ndagijimana, F., and Jomaah, J., 2012. pperformance of Low Profile Dipole Antenna AMC- Based using metamaterial structure. In: 19th International Coference on Telecomunication (ICT). 10. Bayatpur, F., 2009. Metamaterial-Inspired Frequency-Selective Surfaces. The University of Michigan. 11. Bayatpur, F. and Sarabandi, K., 2009a. Multipople Spatial Filters using MetamaterialBased Miniaturized-Element frquency selective surfaces. IEEE Transactions on microwave Theory and Technique, 56 (12), pp.2742–2748. 12. Bayatpur, F. and Sarabandi, K., 2009b. A Metamaterial Frequency-Selective superstrate for phased array application. ieee radar conference. 13. Bayatpur, F. and Sarabandi, K., 2009c. Tuning Performance of Metamaterial-Based Frequency Selective Surfaces, 57 (2), pp.590–592. 14. Bayatpur, F. and Sarabandi, K., 2009. A Tuneable MetaMaterial frequency selective surface with variable modes of operation. IEEE Transactions on microwave Theory and Technique, 57 (6), pp.1433–1438. 15. Bergren, S., 2017. Design Considerations for a 5G Network Architecture, (November), pp.65–75. 16. Beenish, Saraswat, T., Tripathy, M.R., and Mahendru, G., 2016. Design of a High Gain 16 Element Array of Microstrip Patch Antennas for Millimeter wave applications. IEEE Contemporary Computing and Informatics (IC3I), 2016 2nd International Conference on, pp.182–184. 17. Bharti, G., Singh, G., Jha, K.R., and Jyoti, R., 2013. Analysis of Circular Ring Frequency Selective surface at Ka/ Ku Band. IACC, pp.20–23.118 18. Borji, A., Hosseini, M.H., and Sadrearhami, M.H., 2009. 28 GHz High Efficiency Planar Array Antenna with Hybrid Feed Network. IEEE Antennas and Wireless Propagation Letters, pp.7–10. 19. Bunea, A.-C., Craciunoiu, F., and Sajin, G., 2011. 28 GHz CRLH antenna on silicon substrate. European Microwave Week 2011: ‘Wave to the Future’, EuMW 2011, Conference Proceedings - 41st European Microwave Conference, EuMC 2011, (October), pp.579–582. 20. Carver, K.R. and Mink, J.W., 1981. Microstrip Antenna Technology. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 29 (1), pp.2–24. 21. Clenet, M. and Shafai, L., 1999. Wideband single layer microstrip array at 28 GHz. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society International Symposium. 1999 Digest. Held in conjunction with: USNC/URSI National Radio Science Meeting (Cat. No.99CH37010), 3, pp.2106–2109. 22. Chin, K.S., Chang, H.T., Liu, J.A., Chiu, H.C., Fu, J.S., and Chao, S.H., 2011. 28-GHz patch antenna arrays with PCB and LTCC substrates. Proceedings of 2011 Cross Strait Quad-Regional Radio Science and Wireless Technology Conference, CSQRWC 2011, 1, pp.355–358. 23. Dahariya, T., Naik, A., and Patel, P., 2015. Study of 5G Technology, 2 (4), pp.49–53. 24. David.M. Pozar and Daniel H. Schaubert, 1995. Microstrip Antennas, The Analysis and Design of Microstrip Antennas and Arrays". Institute of Electrical and Electronics119 Engineering, Inc. 25. Derneryd, a, 1978. Theoretical Investigation of the Rectangular Microstrip Antenna Element. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 26 (4), pp.532–535. 26. Draft, E., 2011. Fixed Radio Systems; Point to Multipoint Antennas; Antennas for pointto-multipoint fixed radio systems in the11GHz to 60 GHzband; Part 2: 24 GHz to 30 GHz, 0, pp.1–85. 27. El mashed, M. B., & A, H. E. (2018). Design and Analysis of 28GHz Rectangular Microstrip Patch Array Antenna. Wseas Transactions On Communications,17,32 (8),pp.467-470 28. Feng, D., Shenquan, Z., Fan, D., and Dongdong, W., n.d. Designing of New Active Frequency Selective Surface for HPM Protection pp.75–77. 29. G. Ramesh, B. Prakash, J. B. Inder, and I.A., 2001. Microstrip Antenna Design Handbook. london: Artech House Publishers. 30. G.L., W., MU, W., Dai, X.W., and Jiao, Y.C., 2008. Design of Novel Dual-Band Bandpass filter with Microstrip meander-loop resonantor and CSRR DGS. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 78, pp.17–24. 31. Gao, M.J., Wu., L.S., and Mao, J.F., 2012. Compact Notched Ultra-Wideband Bandpass Filter with Improved Out of Band Performance using Quasi Electromagnetic Bandgap structure. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 125, pp.137–150. 32. Gary, B., 2008. An Introduction to Defected Ground Structures in microstrip circiuts. High Frequency Electronics Magazine, 7 (11), pp.50–54. 33. Gujral, M., Li, J.L.W., Yuan, T., and W., Q.C., 2012. Bandwidth Improvement of Microstrip Antenna Array using Dummy EBG pattern on feedline. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 127, pp.79–92.120 34. Haraz, O.M., Ali, M.M.M., Alshebeili, S., and Sebak, A.R., 2015a. Design of a 28/38 GHz dual-band printed slot antenna for the future 5G mobile communication Networks. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society, AP-S International Symposium (Digest), 2015–Octob, pp.1532–1533. 35. Haraz, O.M., Ali, M.M.M., Elboushi, A., and Sebak, A., 2015b. Four-Element Dual-Band Printed Slot Antenna Array for the Future 5G Mobile Communication Networks. 2015 IEEE International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation & USNC/URSI National Radio Science Meeting, pp.1532–1533. 36. Haraz, O.M., Elboushi, A., and Member, S., 2014. Dense Dielectric Patch Array Antenna With Improved Radiation Characteristics Using EBG Ground Structure and Dielectric Superstrate for Future 5G Cellular Networks. IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, 2, pp.909–913. 37. Howell, J.Q., 1972. Microstrip Antennas,. Dig. Int. Symp. Antennas Propogat. Soc, pp.177–180. 38. Imran, M.I., 2012. Open air gap cavity radial line slot array antenna for wireless backhaul application, Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka. 39. Ishfaq, M. K., Tharek, A. R, Yamada, Y., Kumiyo, S., 2017. A 28 GHz Series Fed Patch Antenna Array for 5G Applications. Malaysia-Japan Workshop On Radio Technology 31 (8),pp.324-328 40. Ishfaq, M. K., Tharek, A. R, Yamada, Y., Kumiyo, S., 2017. 8×8 Phased series fed patch antenna array at 28 GHz for 5G mobile base station antennas. (IEEE) Malaysia-Japan121 Workshop on Radio Technology 23(5),pp.507-511 41. J., S.P., 2005. Microstrip Antenna With Different Feeding Methods. Universiti Teknologi Malaysia. 42. James, J. R., and P.S.H. (Eds), 1989. Handbook of Microstrip Antennas. 43. K., O., 2010. Defected Ground Structure and its Application to Microwave Devices and Antenna feed networks. Middle East Technical University. 44. Kapoor, M., 2012. Metamaterials [online]. Available at: http://shodganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/7246/5/chapter_3.pdf [Accessed 27 Apr 2017]. 45. Kiani, G.I., Olsson, L.G., Karlsson, A., Esselle, K.P., and Nilsson, M., 2011. Cross-Dipole Bandpass Frequency selective Suface for Energy-Saving Glass in Building. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 59 (2), pp.520–525. 46. Kim, Y., Yang, F., and Elsherbeni, A.Z., 2007. Compact Artificial Magnetic Conductor Designs Using Planar square spiral Geometries. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 77, pp.43–54. 47. Kraus, J.D. and Marhefka, R.J., 2002. Antennas for all applications. Antennas for all applications, by Kraus, John Daniel; Marhefka, Ronald J. New York: McGraw-Hill, 2002. 48. L., Y., Qi, W.Y., Boxun, X., and Helin, Y., 2012. A Novel Application of Frequency Selecrive surface in Dual-Band WLAN Antnenna. International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation (ISAP). 12(2012),pp.124-128 49. M. Ramesh, K.B.Y., 2003. Design Inset Fed Microstrip Antenna, 42 (dec 2002), pp.41–52. 50. Moghadasi, S.M., Attari, A.R., and Mirasalehi, M.M., 2008. Comparison Between Various Compact Electromagnetic Band Gap (EBG) Structure For Coupling Reduction In Antenna122 Array. international workshop on antenna technololgy : small antennas and novel metamaterials. 26 (1),pp.227-231 51. Munk, B.A., 2000. Frequency-Selective Surface : Theory and Design. New york: John Wiley & Sons. 52. Pendry, J.B., Holden, A.J., Robin, D.., and Stewart, W.., 1999. Magnetism from Conductors and Enhanced Nonlinear Phenomena. IEEE Transactions on microwave Theory and Technique, 47 (11), pp.2075–2084. 53. Pourush, P.K.S., 2001. Microstrip Array Antenna With And Without Airgap In Plasma Environment, 30.(2001),pp.75-79 54. Pozar, D.M., 1992. Microstrip antennas. Proceedings of the IEEE, 80 (1), pp.79–91. 55. Pozar, D.M., 2005. Microwave Engineering. Third Edit. United States: John Wiley and Sons. 56. Rafique, U., Ahmed, M.M., Haq, M.A., and Rana, M.T., 2011. Transmission of RF signals Through Energy Efficient Window using FSS. international conference on Emerging Technologies, pp.1–4. 57. Rahim, M.A.A., Ibrahim, I.M., Kamaruddin, R.A.A., Zakaria, Z., and Hassim, N., 2017. Characterization of microstrip patch array antenna at 28 GHz. Journal of Telecommunication, Electronic and Computer Engineering, 9 (2-8), pp.137–141. 58. Raja Abdullah, R.S.A., Yoharaaj, D., and Ismail, A., 2006. Bandwidth Enhancement Technique in Microstrip Antenna for Wireless Applications. PIERS Online, 2 (6), pp.633– 639. 59. Robert E. Munson, 1973. Microstrip Antenna Structures and Arrays. Third Edit. United States: John Wiley and Sons.123 60. Sarabandi, K. and Behdad, N., 2017. A frequency selective surface with miniaturized elements. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 55, pp.1239–1245. 61. Seng, L.Y., Abd Malek, M.F., Hoon, W.F., Leong, L.W., Saudin, N., Mohamed, L., Affendi, N.A.M., and Ali, A., 2012. Frequency Selective Surface for Enhance WLAN application. IET Microwaves, Antennas & Propagation, pp.81–84. 62. Shirdhar, E.M. and Yogeshwar, P.K., 2011. Metamaterial propertiies and Applications. international Journal of information Technology and knowledgement, 4 (1), pp.85–89. 63. Smith, D.R., Tie, J., C., and Ruopeng, L., 2009. Metamaterials: Theory, Design and Applications. Springer. 64. Society, I.A. and P., 2013. IEEE Standard for Definitions of Terms for Antennas. IEEE Standars association. 65. Sohail, S.I., Esselle, K.P., and Kiani, G., 2012. Design of Band pass FSS on Dual Layer Energy saving glass for improved RF communication in modern building. IEEE international symposium on antenna and propogation, pp.1–7. 66. Space.com, G., 2016. Chapter 2: First Generation Analog Cellular (IHS Engineering 360) [online]. Available at: http://www.globalspec.com/reference/52290/203279/chapter-2-firstgeneration-analog-cellular [Accessed 25 Dec 2016]. 67. Tian, M., Tran, P.D., Hajian, M., and Ligthart, L.P., 1993. Air-Gap Technique For Matching The Aperture Of Miniature Waveguide Antennas. IEEE. 12 (1993) pp.612–619 68. Tie, J.C. and Hui, F.., 2013. Microwave Metamaterial Antennas. Progress In Electromagnetics Research 11 (2013) pp.62-66 69. Ullah, I., Habibi, H., Zhao, X., and Kiani, G., 2011. Design of RF/Microwave Efficient Buidings using Frequency Selective Surface. international symposium on personal, Indoor and Mobile radio Communication, pp.2070–2074.124 70. Umair, R., Khan, M.A., Afzal, M.T., Malik, F., and Qasim, S., 2012. Skewed Frequency Selective Surface Absorber. international journal of advancements in research & Technology, 1 (7), pp.5–8. 71. Vendik, I.B. and Vendik, O.G., 2013. Metamaterial and their application in microwaves : A Review. Zhurnal Teknichesikoi Fiziki, 83 (1), pp.13–28. 72. Veselago, V.G., 1986. The Electrodynamics of substances with simultaneously negative Values of e and m. Soviet physics Uspekhi. 73. Weng, L.H., Guo, Y.C., Shi, X.W., and Chen, X.Q., 2008. An Overview on Defected Ground Structure. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 7, pp.173–189. 74. wikipedia, 2016. History of mobile phones [online]. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_mobile_phones [Accessed 20 Aug 2016]. 75. Wiley, a J., 2005. Antenna Theory Analysis and Design Third Edition. New york: Springer 76. Wu, T.K., 1995. Frequency Selective Surface and Grid Array. New york: John Wiley & Sons. 77. Yablonovitch, E., 1987. Inhibited spontaneous Emission in solid state Physics and electronics. Physics Revision Letters, 58, pp.2059–2062. 78. Yahya, R.S. and Yang, F., 2008. Electronic Bandgap structure in antenna Engineering. cambridge university press. Cambridge, New york.:wiley 79. Yahya, S.A, Yusuf, N.W, Arie, Setiawan, Yuyu, W., 2017 Enhancement of Quasi Yagi Antenna Design for Ka-Band Application. International Conference on Radar, Antenna, Microwave, Electronics, and Telecommunications pp.123–128. 80. Yan, B., Zhang, Y., and Li, L., 2013. Design of Dual-band shared-Aperture Antenna Based on Frequency Selective Surface. International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation125 (ISAP). pp.199-204 81. Yang, Y., Wang, X., H., and Zhou, H., 2012. Dual-Band Frequency Selective Surface with miniaturized element in Low Frequencies. Progress In Electromagnetics Research, 33, pp.167–175. 82. Yongxing, C., Xinyu, H., and Zhengping, G., 2011. A Tuneable Miniaturized-element Frequency selective surface without bias network. ieee intrenational conference on Microwave Technology & computational. pp.59-63 83. Youseifi, L., 2009. Theory, Design and Development of Artificial Magnetic Materials. Ontario, Canada University of Waterloo 84. Yu, L.C. and Kamarudin, M.R., 2016. Investigation of Patch Phase Array Antenna Orientation at 28 GHz for 5G Applications. Procedia Computer Science, 86 (March), pp.47–50. 85. Zacharopoulou, T., 2015. Why LTE is a success? LTE vs WiMAX [online]. Available at: https://0el70lte.wordpress.com/2012/06/29/why-lte-is-a-success-lte-vs-wimax/ [Accessed 29 Nov 2016]. 86. Zahra, H., Abbas, S.M., Shafique, M.F., and Esselle, K.P., 2015. A switchable FSS based on modified Jerusalem- cross unit cell with extended top loading. International Symposium on Antennas and Propagation (ISAP), pp.1–2. 87. Zhang, Y., Jurgen, V., Younis, M., and Wiesbeck, W., 2003. Planar Artificial Magnetic Conductors and patch Antennas. IEEE Antennas and Propagation Society, AP-S International Symposium (Digest), 51 (10), pp.2704–2712